Our Wedding Cake Tasting Experience

All the big celebrations in my life include cake. That’s why I was SO excited when it was time to determine our wedding cake. Not only do I love to taste cake, but I love the idea of a really delicious, unique celebration cake. I wanted to share our process with cake tasting, because I had a few misconceptions that I quickly proved wrong.

  1. Not all bakeries will answer you (just because you want their cake doesn’t mean they will want to bake it).
  2. Cakes taste SO different between baker.
  3. Some cakes just taste plain bad.
  4. The professionalism really matters too.
  5. Keep your mind open.

The first thing I did was find bakeries in my area that had work I liked that I could contact. I reached out to each of them, and most of them didn’t respond (which was very upsetting and actually changed how I view these local bakeries). I kept a list of who I contacted and essential information.

We set up 3 different tastings, and 2 of which did not turn out. There were a variety of complaints I had with both, and while one was a very reputable bakery that just didn’t have the flavor I was going for, the other was a smaller baker that had me so excited, yet really didn’t deliver. Things weren’t mixed (there were literal bombs of flour in the cake), it was burnt, and I didn’t even receive the flavors I ordered. So, both of those were big no nos for me.

Our last tasting turned out to be a show stopper. The cake was so delicious, and we all cleaned our plates. We also loved working with our baker to come up with a sketch of our dream wedding cake. We felt comfortable and confident with every step of the cake process.

We ended up with a delicious, beautifully designed cake from an INCREDIBLE local baker. Not only will it have very minimal yet striking design elements, it also has a fun twist on the inside which makes for the perfect show stopper!

All thoughts and opinions are my own.